Saffron Threadssaffronthreads.com

Substitutes6 min

Fake saffron threads, and the ordinary plants behind them

Safflower, corn silk, turmeric, and paper are fine under their own names. The trouble starts when the label says saffron.

Safflower, marigold petals, turmeric, dyed gelatin, corn silk, and paper all show up wherever saffron is sold loosely. Several of them are fine ingredients when they wear their own names. Turmeric is a dye and a flavor, earthy and sharp. A pinch of it turns rice yellow and tastes like turmeric. Saffron turns rice gold and tastes floral. When a recipe uses both, it should say both.

Patterns that should make you pause

  • Straight, uniform sticks, the same width at both ends, with no trumpet and no bend a flower would grow.
  • Color that rushes out harsh and even in warm water, and a thread that goes pale.
  • A deep red jar with no smell of hay or honey. Old saffron can keep a dye-like color and lose the thing you paid for.
  • A price that is a small fraction of the named ounce jars, about $6 a gram on the day we read them, while the label claims all-red threads and a famous origin.
  • Category I, Super Negin, or Kashmir printed with no harvest, no lab, and no packer you can write to.

A kitchen can keep an obvious bad buy out of the pot. A careful fake can still pass, especially when a little real saffron is mixed into a dyed fiber. Price is a clue, and only a clue. A larger jar of real threads can be the cheaper gram. A tiny price on a nameless pouch is usually a different plant, an old stock, or a lower cut wearing a louder label.

The stand-in is often an ordinary plant. The lie is the name on the pouch.

Also on this desk

Fake saffron threads, and the ordinary plants behind them · Saffron Threads